Skip to content

regulation

Nine Senate Democrats demand CFTC chair Selig reverse Nov 5 prediction-market geofencing order

Schiff-led letter asks CFTC to withdraw its Nov 5 interpretation forcing Kalshi and peers to drop geofencing, citing conflicts with court orders in CA, MI, NV, WA and a tribal injunction.

by 3 min read

Nine Senate Democrats on November 16 sent CFTC Chair Michael Selig a letter demanding the Commission withdraw its November 5 interpretation requiring Designated Contract Markets to end location-based access restrictions within 30 days. They ask for a response by November 23.

Who signed

Led by Sen. Adam Schiff (D-Calif.), the letter is also signed by: Catherine Cortez Masto (D-Nev.), Jacky Rosen (D-Nev.), Maria Cantwell (D-Wash.), Patty Murray (D-Wash.), Elissa Slotkin (D-Mich.), Gary Peters (D-Mich.), Alex Padilla (D-Calif.), and Senate Agriculture Committee Ranking Member Amy Klobuchar (D-Minn.).

What the CFTC did

Selig — the sole sitting commissioner — issued an interpretation on November 5 giving DCMs 30 days to drop geofencing. CoinDesk reports Selig's rationale: "Derivatives markets must operate on a uniform basis at a national scale." The interpretation reads as federal pre-emption of state gambling laws applied to prediction-market contracts offered by Kalshi, Polymarket, Robinhood, Coinbase, Gemini, Crypto.com and others.

What the senators argue

From the letter:

  • "Numerous courts have held that sports-related event contracts are not swaps."
  • "The Commission now appears to be encouraging prediction markets to offer prohibited contracts in contempt of these court orders."
  • "The Commission must withdraw the interpretation or freeze all efforts to implement until litigation is resolved."

The signers want the CFTC to say explicitly that court-ordered, IGRA/tribal-compact-based, and voluntary geographic restrictions do not violate Regulation 38.151(b).

The court record cited

  • Sixth Circuit and Ninth Circuit: both have ruled that states retain authority to apply state gaming laws to prediction markets.
  • Ninth Circuit (preliminary-injunction context): sports event contracts on tribal lands are unauthorized Class III gaming under IGRA.
  • Northern District of California, Blue Lake Rancheria v. Kalshi: an order issued hours before the CFTC's November 5 interpretation requires Kalshi to geofence around the plaintiff tribe's lands.
  • Michigan, Nevada, Washington: courts ordered platforms to stop offering various prediction contracts and imposed geofencing requirements.

What to watch

  1. The November 23 deadline — whether the Commission answers, stays quiet, or pushes ahead with implementation. The 30-day compliance clock runs out December 5.
  2. Confirmation hearings for Nathan Anonick (R) and Matthew Rowland (D) — the only two pending CFTC nominees, set for the Senate Agriculture Committee on November 17, per CoinDesk. A seated commission changes the politics of a sole-commissioner interpretation.
  3. The Louisiana case — Selig called the state suit "naked lawfare," per CoinDesk; a federal judge cleared Louisiana to enforce its ban, and the CFTC itself sued the state. Arkansas filed suit on November 4; the CFTC counter-sued.
  4. Kalshi's response to the N.D. Cal. geofencing order — compliance with the court order is in direct tension with the CFTC interpretation.

Context

The CFTC has now sued roughly a dozen states over prediction-market contracts, per CryptoTimes. The Schiff letter is the second Democratic Senate push this year: Schiff and Cortez Masto led a February letter, signed by 21 Democrats, asking Selig to stay out of pending prediction-market litigation. Today's letter is narrower and more procedural — it asks the chair to pull one specific interpretation — but the conflict between a sole commissioner asserting federal pre-emption and state-court orders in four states plus two tribal injunctions is the thing to keep eyes on.

Related stories