regulation
Kalshi faces Monday TRO hearing before NY Justice Crane
Justice Melissa Crane hears AG Letitia James's TRO bid against Kalshi at 11:30 a.m. ET Monday, Nov. 23. Kalshi says the order would shutter the exchange nationwide.
New York Attorney General Letitia James gets a hearing on her temporary restraining order request against Kalshi on Monday, November 23, 2026 at 11:30 a.m. ET, before Justice Melissa Crane of New York County Supreme Court in Manhattan. The proposed order would bar Kalshi from offering sports, culture, election and other event contracts "within or from New York or to persons in New York." Kalshi, headquartered in New York, says that would shutter the federally registered exchange nationwide. Primary: The Block. Secondary: rg.org on the Crane scheduling order and Kalshi's letter to Crane. Prior coverage: Death Bets Act (S.4035) and Casten-Lieu insider-trading bill.
What's on the table
The proposed TRO would:
- Bar Kalshi from running an unlicensed gambling business from or into New York, covering sports, culture, elections and "other events."
- Bar users under 21 from trading on the platform.
- Bar advertising on college campuses.
Kalshi's counsel Sean Murphy of Milbank argues the order would "shut down a federally regulated exchange for every customer, everywhere," force liquidation of open positions, and conflict with the CFTC's August 11 emergency order directing Kalshi to keep operating. James's office counters it is not seeking a nationwide shutdown and that the order would not stop Kalshi from offering lawful futures or swaps.
How the case got here
- July 31: James sued Kalshi in New York Supreme Court for operating an unlicensed gambling business, seeking up to ~$36 billion in restitution, disgorgement and civil penalties. Same day, Judge Jed Rakoff (SDNY) denied without prejudice the CFTC's emergency TRO seeking to block the state suit.
- August 11: CFTC issued an emergency order directing Kalshi to keep operating despite the state action.
- Nov. 10: In a separate case, Judge Colleen McMahon called the CFTC order a possible "collusive effort" to manufacture a preemption claim.
- Nov. 20 (Friday): Judge Lorna Schofield (SDNY) denied the CFTC's second emergency bid to block James's enforcement case, finding the agency had not shown a strong likelihood of success on Commodity Exchange Act preemption of state gambling laws. Judge Vernon Broderick separately remanded the state case back to state court, rejecting Kalshi's removal to federal court.
- Nov. 23 (Monday): Crane hears the TRO on the schedule she set after a status conference the prior week.
The preemption fight
The CFTC's theory — that event contracts listed on a CFTC-registered designated contract market preempt state gambling laws — is on a losing run. Rakoff rejected it on the merits in July, McMahon called the emergency order collusive in November, and Schofield rejected it again on Friday. James's office urged Crane to give the CFTC's August order no weight, citing McMahon's finding.
Appellate circuits split the other way is also mixed:
- Ninth and Sixth Circuits: ruled against Kalshi.
- Third Circuit: Kalshi's only win — ruling New Jersey gaming regulators cannot ban sports event contracts.
A Supreme Court review is the eventual exit, but no cert petition has been announced.
What Monday decides
The hearing is on a TRO — a preliminary step, not final merits. If Crane grants the full order as requested, Kalshi's sports, culture and election books effectively close to New York IP addresses immediately and, Kalshi argues, globally through the nationwide-shutdown mechanics. If she denies or narrows, the state case continues on the ordinary civil schedule. Either way, James's $36 billion damages prayer stays alive on the merits.
A third path — a narrowed TRO limited to users physically in New York, with the under-21 and college-campus restrictions lifted — is the compromise Kalshi's letter to Crane appears to aim at by stressing its 2021 operating history and the lack of urgency on James's part, since Kalshi has been selling sports contracts since January 2025 without emergency relief sought before now.
What to watch
- Scope of any order — statewide only, or as drafted.
- Treatment of the CFTC August order — a Crane holding that it has no preemptive force would give the next AG action in any state an explicit template.
- Kalshi's appellate move. The First Department (New York's intermediate appellate court) is the next stop if Crane grants. Kalshi will seek an immediate stay.
- CFTC posture. A fourth emergency bid in federal court is the most likely next move; Rakoff, Marrero and Schofield have now all denied CFTC TROs on this theory.
- Sunday night book. Expected pullback of NFL and NCAA contract liquidity on Kalshi ahead of Monday morning if an adverse order is priced in.
Context
This is the third prediction-markets regulatory event in a week on this site — the Senate's Death Bets Act (Nov. 19), the House Casten-Lieu insider-trading bill (Nov. 20), and now the New York TRO hearing. Federal law has moved against what may be listed; state enforcement is moving against where it may be listed. A Crane order against Kalshi's New York book would be the first time a state regulator — rather than Congress or the CFTC — determines the scope of a CFTC-registered event contract venue.