Skip to content

regulation

Supreme Court denies cert in Custodia v. Federal Reserve, ending master-account fight

SCOTUS turned down Custodia Bank's petition on Nov 16, leaving the Tenth Circuit ruling that the Fed has discretion over master accounts in place. Docket 26-62.

by 3 min read

The U.S. Supreme Court on November 16 denied certiorari in Custodia Bank, Inc. v. Federal Reserve Board of Governors (No. 26-62), closing Custodia's four-year legal fight for a Fed master account. The denial appears on Monday's order list without comment, as is standard for cert denials.

What happened

Custodia, a Wyoming-chartered special-purpose depository institution founded by Caitlin Long, applied to the Kansas City Fed for a master account in 2020. The Kansas City Reserve Bank denied the application in January 2023, citing concerns about Custodia's crypto-focused business model. Custodia sued over the 19-month delay and, after the denial, pivoted to arguing that the Monetary Control Act of 1980 requires access for legally eligible nonmember institutions.

A district judge sided with the Fed in 2024. The Tenth Circuit affirmed in October 2025, holding that Reserve Banks retain discretion over master-account applications. In March, the full Tenth Circuit denied rehearing en banc. Custodia petitioned the Supreme Court in July. The Blockchain Association filed an amicus brief in August backing review.

What a master account means

A Federal Reserve master account gives an eligible institution direct access to the Fed's payment rails and the most direct access to the money supply available to financial institutions. Without one, a bank has to route payments through a correspondent that does — adding counterparty risk and operational layers. The Block reports that attention now shifts to the Fed's proposed "skinny master account," which would not pay interest and would not allow discount-window borrowing.

Why it matters

  • The Tenth Circuit holding stands as the governing law of that circuit: Reserve Banks have discretion to grant or deny master accounts to otherwise-eligible applicants.
  • The decision leaves crypto-focused banks without a judicial path to force access. Any route now runs through policy — a redesigned product (the skinny account), congressional action, or a different Fed posture.
  • The question the Court declined asks whether a Reserve Bank president can refuse an account to a legally eligible nonmember. That remains unresolved on the merits; a denial of cert sets no precedent of its own.

What to watch

  1. The Fed's "skinny master account" rulemaking — timing, final scope, and whether it draws meaningful interest from Wyoming-chartered or similar state crypto banks.
  2. Any next move from Caitlin Long's team; Custodia did not immediately respond to The Block's request for comment.
  3. Downstream effects on Wyoming's Special Purpose Depository Institution framework, the only state charter class built around digital-asset custody at the state level.
  4. Treatment of similar applications still sitting at other Reserve Banks.

Context

Kraken's banking unit became the first digital-asset bank to receive Fed payment-system access, under a Kansas City Fed-issued limited-purpose account earlier this year, per Bitcoin Magazine. The case law and the policy are now pointing in opposite directions: a court-side regime that lets Reserve Banks say no, and an infrastructure-side regime where selected crypto-adjacent firms are being let in through a different product. Custodia loses the former path; whoever else wants the account now watches the latter.

Related stories